Hello Yuv & Yusuf,
Thank you for your response.
On 1/7/2016 11:37 PM, Yuv Joodhisty wrote:
> I second what Yusuf has said. None of them relates something to the
> internet according to me.
So, according to you, this is does not relate to the internet. I just
have a little question, from which perspective did you analyse the logo?
From a developer, designer, layman, internet user?That's just to
understand from what perspective you are commenting.
> I'd also vote for 11 as it is simple (with colours) and easy to
> understand while the others have some "designs" which barely
> communicate stuff to me.
Okay, do you have any other suggestions that can help me get to your
taste and communicate stuff to you?
> Well, i find the choice of colours good. It's not
>
>
> Red, Blue, Yellow and Green
> but instead some matching colours which can be related to Mauritius.
I guess this comment was useful enough compared to the other ones :)
> On Thu, Jan 7, 2016 at 10:16 PM, Yusuf Satar <fx_at_fluxy.net
> <mailto:fx_at_fluxy.net>>wrote:
>
> I fail to understand the meaning of the graphic in logos 4, 5, 9,
> 10, 12, 13 and 14; at best it looks like a (very) messy mail icon
> to me - the mail aspect is not bad per se, since it is a mailing
> list; for NOW, but this may change in the future.
>
I will write a separate email to describe the logo/emblem in details.
> The two other graphics in 7 and 8 give me a feeling of déjà vu,
> but I cannot remember where.
>
Okay.
>
> Thus no graphic seem to convey the concept of Internet or use
> thereof as far as I am concerned, whereas the Mauritian aspect
> seem to be covered by the background in logos 10 and 11.
>
Actually, some managed to dig a little bit to understand what the logos
you failed to understand meant. I will facilitate your work in my next
email.
> My vote would be none of the logos; but if I really HAD to, it
> would be logo 11.
>
Thank you.
> I must apologize for being so blunt for I would definitely be
> unable to produce a logo half the quality of any of those you have
> proposed yet it is difficult for me to comment otherwise.
>
Indeed, I should thank you for your response and that's how responses
should be. Criticism is the key to the perfect logo and from your
response, I managed to gather information that would surely help me to
do another logo that would certainly be appreciated by users.
Logo design involves lots of psychological understanding.
Apart from that, I have a question for both of you. I am sure you know
about CodePen [1], the famous front-end developer code playground. They
do have a logo [2]. My question is, what can you say about the logo with
respect to the site?
[1]
http://codepen.io/
[2]
https://pbs.twimg.com/profile_images/2309242092/7um0112y4n9pvvlcodkl_400x400.png
--
Regards,
*Tejas (Nirvan) Pagooah*
CTO, Graphics Temple
Received on Fri Jan 08 2016 - 09:48:43 PST
